1. 2=1 problem:
Given:
a = b
Multiply by a:
a2 = ab
Subtract b2
a2 - b2 = ab - b2
Factor:
(a + b)(a - b) = b(a - b)
Jason: [
Wrong! (a-b) is zero, the equation cannot be divided by (a-b) ]
Divide (a - b): (a + b) = b
Substitute the given:
a + a = a
Simplify:
2a = a
Divide by a:
2 = 1
2. Where is one dollar? (part 1)
Three business executives eat lunch in a restaurant. They estimate that the
bill should come to $30. They split the bill 3 ways and pay 10 dollars each.
When the actual bill comes, it is $25. Since this is not divisible by three,
they each take a dollar back and leave the extra two dollars tip for the waiter.
Since each paid nine dollars and nine times three is 27, plus two for the waiter
is 29. Where did the other dollar go?
Jason: [The
logic is not correct. They paid
$27. $25 for bill, $2 for tips.
There is no such $1 missing.]
3. Where is one dollar? (part 2)
A restaurant manager bought two piles of oranges from a suppliers at
different time. In the morning the supplier wants $10 for thirty oranges, or
three for a dollar. In the afternoon, the same supplier wants $15 for 30 oranges
for, or two for a dollar. The manager decides to count all sixty at five for two
dollars. After multiplying by twelve, sixty oranges cost only $24, but he needed
$25 dollars for the suppliers. Where is the other dollar?
Wilson: [If the manager
counts by multiplying "five for two" by twelve, meaning he bought 36
oranges at "three for a dollar" and only 24 oranges at "two for a
dollar".]
4. Where is the unit?
Jason: [The slope of the bottom
triangle is not a straight line. The
trick is on the size of triangles.]
Wilson: [Actually both triangles are not straight, top one is a little convex
and the bottom one is a little concave.]
Wilson
--
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
ICQ 2417224